Trash service issue could be on November ballot

The trash service issue isn’t over for Joel Culberson. And if he can pull off a large task in the next 62 days, the issue will be in front of a larger voting block.

Prior to a vote by the Fort Smith Board of Directors to exempt 20 remaining neighborhoods from automated trash service by the Fort Smith Department of Sanitation, Culberson made an impassioned plea for the Board members to consider the cost efficiencies and safety for city employees in fully converting to an automated system.

The city’s Department of Sanitation has automated 24,578 households, with 4,095 remaining.

The Board, voting 4-3, eventually supported the wishes of a vocal group of residents who said the automated system was too much of an inconvenience for their older neighborhoods.

The deal is not finished for the pro-automation Culberson, who is a resident of Park Hill East, the first neighborhood exempted from automated service.

“I live in Park Hill East. ... I know a little something about this,” Culberson said, adding that he believes a majority in the neighborhoods exempted want the modern, automated service. “I was in the majority of the first two surveys who said they wanted it, but they (City Board) said, ‘Nope,’ and they took it away.”

He believes in it so much that he told the Board he has launched a petition drive to gather 2,822 valid voter signatures by Aug. 8 to place the issue before a vote of all citizens.

“I know it will take a lot of work to do that. It may be hard to get people motivated because it doesn’t have a large amount of money tied to it,” Culberson said, adding that over time, he believes the efficiencies of a modern trash program will save hundreds of thousands if not millions of dollars for the city.

To gather a base of supporters, Culberson sent an FOIA request to City Directors about their correspondence with citizens on the issue. City Directors George Catsavis, Don Hutchings and Steve Tyler did not reply to the request.

But Culberson did gather between 2,500 and 3,000 e-mails, with many, according to Culberson, supportive of automation. From that list, he has about 100 people who he plans to contact to see if they will actively support his against-the-odds effort to gather signatures.

Culberson said he plans to rely primarily on “social media and a lot of grassroots” support to get the word out. His “VoteforAutomated” Facebook page is the first push in his social media effort.
www.facebook.com/VoteForAutomated

Advertisement:

“I hope so,” Culberson said when asked if he could really gather 2,822 signatures in just over 60 days. “But if nothing else, it should get people involved, informed and engaged.”

City Director Kevin Settle believes the effort, if it makes it to the ballot, could be a success. In his comments prior to the Board vote, Settle rhetorically asked his Board peers how roughly 85% of Fort Smith residents with automated service will vote if they see that trash service rates will increase if automation is not fully implemented.

Five Star Votes: 
Average: 4.8 (6 votes)

Comments

Thank you Mr. Culberson for

Thank you Mr. Culberson for stepping up and voicing the opinion of the citizen MAJORITY!

Cheers

Cheers to Kevin Settle for seeing the reality of the situation. And a great big cheers to Joel Culberson for undertaking this. It may entail much kicking and screaming but hopefully we can drag the curmudgeons into the 20th century (not a typo, seriously this technology isn't that new or scary. Of course most places got flouride in the water 50 years ago.)

CartMudgeons

So why do you insult people by referring to disabled people as carmudgeons or customers who want to opt out of any trash pickup as carmudgeons?

whatever!

Go away troll, it's been well discussed that the elderly and disabled can request the Hot Shot service. Curmudgeon accurately describes those that can move their trash like the rest of the city, but want to cry about it.

Where do i sign as well?

Seriously, post some dates and times, and my whole neighborhood will come.

The petition language and

The petition language and ballot title are currently under review by legal counsel, but we expect to be able to begin collecting signatures in the very near future. Please "like" our facebook page (http://www.facebook.com/VoteForAutomated) or sign up on our website (http://www.voteforautomated.com/contact/) to be notified as soon as our signature collection campaign begins.

-------------------------------------------------------------
http://www.voteforautomated.com
http://www.facebook.com/VoteForAutomated

Petition Drive

I am willing to go door to door. Please let me know as soon as the petitions are ready. Together, the majority of our residents voices can be heard and show Mr Merry and Catsavis that the good of the many outweigh the concerns of the few. please contact me at 479-459-0785.

Bully Voters

I would support your cause if you didn't ram it down my throat as you won't allow me to discontinue my trash service so as not to pay for what I don't need. So how is what you espouse fair and just. Like someone else said, "tyranny of the majority".

No sympathy

Welcome to living in a municipality. Do you whine about the flavor of the city water? If you want to be able to ala carte and pay for premium services, move into the county.

Inhospitable Invitation accepted

Keep going good citizen of the municipality, more emigrants will oblige you....just what Fort Smith needs.

Whatever

Go on and move into the country, I'm sure the governor will soon see a complaint stating you don't like the way the crickets chirp at night and want them removed. Your self-entitlement highlights what is wrong with this country.

What is the requirement for

What is the requirement for Mr. Catsavis, Mr. Hutchings, and Mr. Tyler to respond to the FOIA request? May they ignore it with impunity?

Trash service issue

I did some research on automated curb trash pickup and found these statements from cities in Arkansas and other cities across the country: ..garbage collection day won’t win any beautification awards in any neighborhood. But with the uniform appearance of the automated carts on your street, the neighborhood will certainly look a lot neater on collection day. The carts are also made to be user friendly for homeowners: • They roll easily to the curb, so there’s no more heavy lifting when it’s time to “take out the garbage.” • The carts have tight fitting lids to keep out animals and other pests while reducing the chance of windblown litter. • And since all the carts look alike, neighborhoods will have a more pleasant appearance on collection day. _ Decrease labor requirements. _ Reduce the number of vehicles required to serve a collection territory. _ Reduce injury potential associated with fatigue and lifting. _ Reduce litter and unsightly set-outs ● Labor demands can be reduced significantly—most often, fully automated vehicles are operated by one-person crews. ● Greater diversity is possible in hiring drivers (physical lifting capabilities are not a requirement). ● Worker comfort is increased—drivers rarely need to leave the cab (reduces exposure to weather). ● Worker safety is enhanced: — Operator fatigue is minimized. — Manual lifting is eliminated. — Potential injury risk associated with larger crews is minimized. — Workers’ compensation costs often decrease. — Job longevity is increased; less turnover.
I did some research on automated curb trash pickup and found these statements from cities in Arkansas and other cities across the country: ..garbage collection day won’t win any beautification awards in any neighborhood. But with the uniform appearance of the automated carts on your street, the neighborhood will certainly look a lot neater on collection day. The carts are also made to be user friendly for homeowners: • They roll easily to the curb, so there’s no more heavy lifting when it’s time to “take out the garbage.” • The carts have tight fitting lids to keep out animals and other pests while reducing the chance of windblown ...>> Read the entire comment.

Roll easily on what surface?

"They roll easily to the curb, so there’s no more heavy lifting when it’s time to “take out the garbage" Not on a slope or uneven lawns without paved walkway or broken concrete sidewalks.....anything else?

Yeah, I'll tell you what else

even out your lawn, fix your broken walkway. Don't make your problem my problem

Exactly

I second that, take care of your property - those trash cans are very mobile, and I guarantee my driveway is steeper than yours.

All You Can Eat

Faced with rising cost, a local restaurant changed formats and advertised, "All you Can Eat $5.99" and business was good. One day, two families came into the restaurant and saw eight other families enjoying their food. Despite knowing the format, they sat down and asked for menus. "I'd just like to be served," one of them was heard to say. Their meals came and it was time to drop them their bill. The restaurant owner didn't know what to do. "Well, we can just ignore the fact that we just paid the waiter overtime and our kitchen costs just went up, to hell with ever modernizing the place. We could just charge everyone in the place an extra buck, maybe they won't notice. Or maybe we dust off the old menu and figure out how much our prices went up." Now, how do you think those buffet diners are going to feel about getting a $6.75 bill for their buffet dinners? I think I just heard one of those served families say, "I'm not about to pay ten bucks for what's been advertised as a $5.99 buffet."
Faced with rising cost, a local restaurant changed formats and advertised, "All you Can Eat $5.99" and business was good. One day, two families came into the restaurant and saw eight other families enjoying their food. Despite knowing the format, they sat down and asked for menus. "I'd just like to be served," one of them was heard to say. Their meals came and it was time to drop them their bill. The restaurant owner didn't know what to do. "Well, we can just ignore the fact that we just paid the waiter overtime and our kitchen costs just went up, to hell with ever modernizing the place. We could just charge everyone in the place an extra buck, maybe they ...>> Read the entire comment.

False Analogy

The customers could always eat somewhere else. With trash pickup we are not given a choice to hire a competitor, it is a monopolistic mandatory service itemized on a monthly bill with other charges. I suppose you support mandatory government health insurance aka OBAMA CARE or Massachusetts ROMNEYCARE?