Wal-Mart Stores criticized for not matching online prices

story by Kim Souza

Retail giant Wal-Mart might claim to be a constant low cost leader and match other retailers’ sale prices, but it does not match its online prices and makes no apologies for that policy.

The retailer outlines its policy on its website: “The merchandise and prices on our website do not reflect the merchandise and prices available in our stores. Our stores will not match prices with our online store (or other online prices) because we do not consider them to be in competition with our retail stores. Currently, we do not have access to store inventory lists or price lists at this website.”

Clark Howard, a nationally syndicated consumer advice writer, finds it hard to understand that a retailer claiming to “bridge the intersection of physical and digital” refused to give him the lower online price for a Lego set he recently tried to purchase for his son. The Atlanta Journal Constitution published his report about the experience.

Retail experts from across country have weighed in on this policy at RetailWire, most finding Wal-Mart ‘s actions toward Howard to be a step-back and a poor lesson in customer service.

“Retailers may have their reasons for not matching their own online prices, but to consumers those reasons don't make any sense. Whether it's Walmart, Gap, Target or other stores, all these policies serve to do is make consumers mad. Retailers should do a better job of explaining the practice or drop it,” according to Max Goldberg, president of Max Goldberg Associates.

Other experts like Frank Riso note that Wal-Mart will have to learn that it cannot manage its inventory with two different price models using their stores as pick-up and return centers.

“The consumer knows only Wal-Mart and not Wal-Mart Stores versus Walmart.com. It has taken at least 10 years for retailers to realize that the consumer only knows the brand and not the channel. Wal-Mart will learn, just give them time to reflect on it,” Riso added. He is the principal of Riso & Associates.

Jason Goldberg, vice president of at Razorfish, said the dual pricing policy is “horrible” because with a customer “it's all Wal-Mart.” The differences in overhead costs in the distinct channels are irrelevant to the consumer, Goldberg added. He said it’s out-of-character for the “Always Low Prices” retailer.

“In this world of perfect information and complete pricing transparency, consumers will know they aren't getting the best price from Wal-Mart and will always have to fear that they should be getting a better price — exactly what Walmart doesn't want,” Goldberg said.

Ironically, Wal-Mart has invested millions in advertising campaigns that promote its low in-store prices and recently vowed to roll out its “Savings Catcher” program and expand it to include general merchandise and produce. Wal-Mart has said its Savings Catcher program is about reassuring consumers that they are getting the lowest price when they shop at Wal-Mart’s physical stores. Goldberg notes that consumers may not buy the story given that store prices aren’t even Walmart’s best prices.


Other experts believe Wal-Mart has no choice but to try and match Amazon pricing online, which are apt to change throughout the day. The constant price changes in-store would be problematic. That said, when a consumer asks for the lower online price while in-store and that item will be filled from that supercenter, most believe the correct policy for Wal-Mart is to give that customer the lower price immediately.

“We're definitely seeing some growing pains as new models emerge for retailers to figure out how to do omnichannel. The problem here is that positioning the stores as being in competition with the website seems entirely bizarre, and that message will likely change,” said Matt Schmitt, president of Reflect.

Five Star Votes: 
Average: 5 (4 votes)

Like This Article? Share It!


Target DOES price-match with their website

So I suspect this policy won't last long if WM is truly serious about being a big player online.

The last time I tried to price match at Walmart...

was literally the last time I tried because...I got the idea. It was one of those entire tool kits disguised as a set of pliars. It looked exactly the same as the one in the ad but the number in the ad was something like 4567893325476789 and the number on the one in Walmart was 4567893325476789/WM. Nope not the same model..they have different numbers. Gotcha. Meanwhile what the guy has let slip right by him is Walmart has now dropped down to XLarge on some things with their infamous 'Fat Boy' price penalty from double/triple X.

Positive Experience with Price matching

My husband went in to our local Walmart to purchase a new sewing machine for me as a birthday present. I had mentioned that the price was lower on Walmart's website and that if they didn't want to honor it, we could simply opt for the free in store pick up (at the very same store since it was instock). He mentioned this to the clerk in customer service and she matched it to the online price! If she hand't, we would've used the "in store pick up" loophole but I think it saved her sometime by simply overriding the price instead of having to process the pick up. Going to try to see if they will match the sale price for a different item at another online company today. If they don't, I'll simply purchase on the other site that offers free shipping. It's on sale for half the price walmart has it for. Worth a shot!